Showing posts with label disability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label disability. Show all posts

Monday, December 1, 2014

The Gated Autism Community Part 2; The Solution

I recently wrote in a Facebook status update about the exclusivity of the so-called online autism community. I was asked to expand on this idea and give it a title. I did and it was posted where people not on my friends list would have access. The response indicated it wasn't appreciated.

First, points were subtracted from my overall grade for how the way I wrote was incomprehensible. One woman asked someone else to explain because it bogged her down. When I offered to answer a question, she neglected to ask one. She told me that it read like a medical textbook, and she was just a grandma who needed things in layman terms. Upon hearing I hadn't graduated elementary school, and my jobs only included manual labor, she said she hadn't meant to hurt my feeling and gave cyber hugs.  

Next I received a poor grade for the way the essay was lacking in a conclusion or a solution. (This, of course, is something I may have learned had I attended essay writing class.) Without such a thing, the theme was dismissed as nothing more than complaining about an uncurable societal ill rather than joining the ranks of those who were supposedly willing to address that which could be addressed.  

Those commenting consistently referred to me as if I wasn't involved in the conversation long after I'd clearly shown that I was. One, in particular, told of what Mr. Ised (meaning me) doesn't understand and is wrong about and included passive-aggressive questions implying what I may have meant. She identified herself as one of the people with Asperger's who had pushed for the needed change and suggested that rather than include more whose contributions go unrecognized, we should all be more respectful and appreciative of her hard work and that of others like her.

People said they weren't following the point yet they wrongly assumed what it was and critiqued it. Ideas were taken completely out of context so the writer could be discredited, and the content could be ignored. Despite my request for specific questions, some continued to ask for the central point of what I wrote as though I had intentionally neglected to explain as best I could. I was even told that what I write was full of smoke, and that I should have instead used my own words.

More than one person, commenting asserted that although I had failed to communicate effectively, I shouldn't claim to advocate for those who were poorer communicators. I once followed with this but received no response;  
"Further separating a marginalized group for the sake of convenience into contribution-ignored and struggle-ignored subs will only help to ensure no one but others will ever decide policy that affects them or influences the way society describes them. If someone ever does contribute recognizably, they're simply placed into the other category so the status remains the same."

It's convenient to describe the autism spectrum as ranging from people with assets to those with deficits. This fits with age-appropriate standards, the way developmental disability is defined, and the traditional emergency-room means for acquiring services. It also encourages the way people are seeking association and endorsements of so-called important people while further suggesting that the excluded are unimportant. Nothing could be more backwards.

Inclusion is nothing like the politicians describe. They can't alter the system but need to claim progress in order to be appointed or reelected. If a community was truly interested in inclusion, they would first recognize more of the contribution currently being ignored and create something that the so-called support system either can't or won't.  

Politicians and scholars will present a problem either as either the catalyst for debate or in such a manor that they aren't expected to address it. I, on the other hand, have no reason to do either. As I mentioned earlier, a mountain top or birds's eye view is not an advantage unless the people who are being decided for are the focus. If their contribution is believed to be insignificant, the claim that they are being served is disingenuous at best.

People communicate when they have a reason. They will best be able to explain what access entails when they are viewed as the primary source of solutions. The point of describing the autism community as gated is to highlight how people are being excluded who shouldn't be. The solution to exclusion is simply inclusion. Whenever a method of exclusion has been better understood, anyone wanting to avoid it will be more equipped to do so.

Friday, November 28, 2014

The Gated Autism Community

No matter what autism statistic is most accurate, there are few participating in online discussions, which affect policy as well as society's perceptions. Therefore, this shouldn't be called an autism community. 
It would be fine to claim that the goal was to be inclusive. However, those who are most excluded aren't the bullies but rather their victims. This fits well with the suggestion that we need more celebrities representing us and raising our status above that of the disabled. With such exclusionary goals, there's nothing representative about this so-called community.
In an environment with true representation, many of the therapies would be described in a completely different way and may be abolished. Furthermore, if those who were diagnosed began to believe they were regarded as worthy of influencing the policy decisions that affected them, more abuse would be reported, and society would have less means of segregation.
Integration is mainly just presented as an unrealistic ideal by politicians who want to be reelected. It works similarly to the goal of curing incurable societal ills. The decision makers are afraid the diagnosed may truly integrate if they get too much of the support they need so they need excuses the valued public will accept. One way disabled people's exclusion is traditionally justified is by the claim they are morally inferior. The idea of inability and differences in access requirements, communication, perception, and expression are far too inconvenient. Instead, it works much better when it's suggested that people are lazy, immature, stubborn, and unwilling.
People who aren't influencing policy aren't neglecting to take on the task. Their inconvenient ranking prohibits them from doing so. No one believes the cart-before-the-horse approach to inclusion will do anything but protect the status quo. Nevertheless, people who need supports are expected to prove their worthiness before they can explain what support they need. People qualified to provide answers aren't be allowed to participate.
The traditional political arena honors standard hierarchical ranking and equates those with the lower ranks with deserving blame, punishment, and being ignored. It's suggested that those with a bird's eye or mountain-top view have earned their position, and others just aren't willing. Such people's lack of education and experience or their ignorance (these really are viewed as inseparable) classifies them as worthless.
In order to protect tradition those whose contribution is valued are believed to have already over-come the obstacles which others are facing. Having only a few contributions valued, and everyone expected to follow one of the few approved paths prevents any challenge to the traditional system and those who benefit from it. Not only is diversity perceived as a threat to the system and those involved in it, it's those whose perspective is different and those who will offer new and alternative approaches that are needed most in creating policy that will aid in their success as well as more success of others.
The online discussions concerning autism aren't public at all. The only people participating are society's valued members. The only way it can be considered a community is if the word gated is added as a prefix. As an extension of the system which promotes traditional values, re-electing politicians is all that will be accomplished.

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

The Best Thinking

No forms of ableism are more socially acceptable than the ones which imply a lack of intelligence or sanity. Few will object to someone being called stupid, crazy or something similar. Furthermore, the questions asked at a competency hearing will put to rest the myth that there's any separation between intellect and emotional/mental stability within the law or in cultural attitudes. It's widely believed that such a deficit can be related to someone's character. When it's implied that it is, it's more likely to be seen as justified and as though what's said doesn't offend other people.

Partisan politics play a vital role in promoting the problem and protecting those who instigate it. Free-market capitalism allows universities to deny most people, an education and some popular conservatives are preaching an anti-science and anti-intellectual message. At the same time, their liberal opposition is educating more people in elitist language and etiquette, which are called other names but stink just as bad and cause as many problems. It may be suggested that since the scholars create the rules, what they learn will trickle down like resources supposedly do. Furthermore, the implication may be that the uninvolved can't support the needed change. However, the claim that bigotry is the result of ignorance, which stems from the lack of education will support how people without monetary resources are believed to have nothing to contribute and are prohibiting progress.

One standard for ranking by which some are exalted and others unfairly excluded, marginalised, disenfranchised, and abused works as well as any other. Inclusion has been commercialized and subsequently, and the ideal diluted so that advocates who are appointed to challenge what's causing the problem are instead promoting it.

Wednesday, December 4, 2013

Public Opinion

Only a small portion of the public is valued and has an opinion considered valid. Furthermore, what passes for solidarity rarely includes many ideas or, more importantly, many people who are providing alternatives to tradition. That which is commonly referred to as a democratic approach is often something very different. The prohibition of alternate views is never written in a formal rule book where it can be easily challenged. Instead, there's a consistent supply of subtle methods for blaming those who don't follow the prescribed plan. 

For example, the Internet continues to be small with very limited access. It would be helpful if discussions described as open and public would acknowledge this limitation, but that rarely happens. Usually when it is described as a tool for liberation, the describer has either been misled by popular culture or is just intentionally deceptive. Believing that inclusion exists long before it does will require ignoring the exclusionary methods being used. 

There are plenty of convenient ways to describe negatively those who aren't welcome (non-team player, selfish, willingly ignorant and/or poor, unnecessarily individualistic, antagonistic, etc.), and until this is no longer comfortable, the limited solution options that result will prevent progress. 

Those which are called the best ways to provide access and encourage inclusion are decided by authorities rather than by those who need support. Since needing support is synonymous with lacking understanding of what is important, the decision-making process is left to those who have been granted the privilege of calling what they think knowledge without it being adequately challenged. 

Much of what is discussed regarding the way diagnosis is used for people not fitting in or relating to others in a substandard way is limited to those who profit from problems continuing. The public follows the authority by pointing out what they see is lacking in others in a way that promotes their own status. 

The division between those who have the authority to participate in influential discussions and decide policy and those who don't, follows a similar trend as income and class division. The advertised way for people to overcome their position encourages the belief that people who are least respected don't contribute anything valuable and are therefore, disposable. This also encourages unrealistic expectations. Until what gets called public opinion is the result of hearing what many people think who are seen to have an inadequate or uneducated view, the definition of empowerment will be misleading and the goals which are set will continue to be unmet.   

Monday, December 2, 2013

A Valid Argument

As I wrote in my last post, exclusion is often subtle. More importantly, those who understand it best have fewer opportunities to describe the problem. Therefore, what passes for factual information remains unchallenged and is generally false. 

Inclusion can be nothing more than a buzz word or a brand name. People who have spent time, energy, and possibly money on learning at prestigious establishments, more commonly known as schools, think in limited ways and often need to devalue the contribution of others in order to maintain their overly inflated status.  

My experiences with blogging and with social network sites remind me that educated people may read what I write. As I've been told, in no uncertain terms, some will expect me to not only continually remind readers of my complete lack of education, but also I'm expected not to write in any way that cannot be easily distinguished from the way valued people say things. A valued person is someone who has been granted the privilege of using condescending language to insult those who were not issued the license that they were, and they will justify the harm done by describing others as willfully ignorant.  

This license permits them to call what they have learned information. It is otherwise known as a diploma or degree. The ones who issue them teach a set of rules branded as logical, which supposedly regulate arguments, debates, and influential discussions. Since others haven't learned these rules, we accept what is said by people called experts with letters after their name. Perhaps these people are aware of the unfairness and maybe not. I've never heard one of them acknowledge it though. 

It might seem unlikely that this would happen within a community defining their goal as the encouragement of diversity and the empowerment of those with needs considered special. However, my experience indicates that it happens quite often. 

Those who have special talents may also have special needs. A few may even be able to market their services as a result of conventional talent. It's important though, to avoid having an advocacy effort become ineffective due to sending a hypocritical message. 

If the only exclusion being discouraged is that which can be identified by the flashing neon lights on a giant billboard, most of it will remain protected and effective. It's inconvenient to accept those who communicate in a different way and have a unique perspective but without attempting to do this, not much that needs to be challenged will be.